Wednesday, October 4, 2023
Green Reporter
  • Home
  • Biodiversity
  • Climate Change
  • Energy
  • Filmmaking
  • Food
  • Investment
  • Management
  • Sustainability
  • Technology
  • Transportation
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Biodiversity
  • Climate Change
  • Energy
  • Filmmaking
  • Food
  • Investment
  • Management
  • Sustainability
  • Technology
  • Transportation
No Result
View All Result
Green Reporter
No Result
View All Result
Home Climate Change

Climate change, migration: How Merkel’s successors measure up | Germany| News and in-depth reporting from Berlin and beyond | DW

GrR by GrR
July 21, 2021
in Climate Change
0
Climate change, migration: How Merkel’s successors measure up | Germany| News and in-depth reporting from Berlin and beyond | DW
55
SHARES
241
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


In September 2021, Germany will elect a new federal parliament, and change chancellors as well. Three major parties have put up candidates hoping to succeed Angela Merkel, who will not run again after 16 years in office.

Merkel’s own party, the Christian Democrats (CDU), nominated Armin Laschet for the candidacy. Laschet serves as state premier of North Rhine-Westphalia, Germany’s most populous state. The Greens, meanwhile, made 40-year-old international law expert Annalena Baerbock their candidate, the party’s first candidacy with real prospects of success. The Social Democrats (SPD) tipped Finance Minister Olaf Scholz as their top candidate. With the party at around 20% in the polls, Scholz is currently deemed unlikely to win the chancellorship.

What voting records reveal

Voting records provide an overview of how the governing parties have implemented their promises and how the opposition parties have positioned themselves politically.

In Germany, several parties usually form a majority coalition that votes unanimously, and whose motions will thus generally pass. Much depends, therefore, on the formation of the next coalition, and the deals struck in the process. For most of her time in office, Merkel oversaw a “grand coalition” of CDU/CSU and SPD, with the Greens in the opposition.

Should the SPD go into opposition after this election, it could cast its vote separately from the conservatives for the first time since 2013. And should the greens become a government party, they will have to compromise with their coalition partners.

So, what is each candidate’s track record so far? And what does that tell us about Germany’s future chancellor? To find the politicians’ signature issues, DW assessed the words and phrases each of the candidates use more often than their competitors in parliamentary speeches.

  • Data visualization Germany chancellor candidate comparison speeches Laschet

    What Merkel’s potential successors talk about in parliament

    Armin Laschet: State premier and family minister

    In recent years, the CDU chairman has been mostly active in state- and regional-level politics. That focus is reflected in his speeches, in which he mentions his home state and its political institutions more often than his fellow campaigners. His time as Integration and Family Minister from 2005 to 2010 also stands out, with mentions for parents, children and education.

  • Data visualization Germany chancellor candidate comparison speeches Baerbock

    What Merkel’s potential successors talk about in parliament

    Annalena Baerbock: Climate and Europe

    Annalena Baerbock’s characteristic issues stand out in her parliamentary speeches: She mentions climate policy, Germany’s coal phase-out and Europe more often than her competitors. Her home state of Brandenburg also makes an appearance: Baerbock comes from and is a member of parliament for Potsdam, near Berlin.

  • Data visualization Germany chancellor candidate comparison speeches Scholz

    What Merkel’s potential successors talk about in parliament

    Olaf Scholz: German finance minister and Hamburg mayor

    The SPD politician is active in both state and federal politics. He was mayor of Hamburg from 2011 to 2018 and, accordingly, often speaks about the city and its local politics. As a former labor minister and current finance minister, he mentions workers and the economy more often than the other two candidates.

    Author: Kira Schacht


Whether issues and policy positions of politicians are put into practice is partly decided in the federal and state parliaments. Here, political positions are discussed and new laws voted on. DW gathered all roll-call votes the candidates and Merkel participated in, recorded by the German parliamentary watchdog NGO Abgeordnetenwatch, and manually labeled them by international relevance and policy issue. What is their track record on migration, environmental policy, or European cooperation?

Merkel’s mixed migration record

Merkel’s decision not to close the borders to refugees stranded in Hungary in 2015 was watched around the world. Overall, however, the chancellor’s voting record on migration and refugee policy is rather mixed. Less than a quarter of her votes support a more open migration policy. Instead, her governing coalition voted, for example, against deportation stops for Syrian refugees, which the Greens had requested in 2011, or introduced a motion to classify Algeria, Morocco, Tunisia and Georgia as safe countries of origin in 2019.

Data visualization Germany chancellor candidate comparison migration

Political calculations play a big role in such votes, says Ulrich Sieberer, professor of empirical political science at the University of Bamberg: “99% of the time, votes are about positioning yourself in the conflict between government and opposition.”

Opposition parties like the Greens can introduce motions to parliament, but these have no chance of success without the support of the governing coalition. But they still serve a purpose, says Sieberer: “From the opposition’s point of view, it’s an instrument to present one’s own position to the voters, and to show up the government by occasionally forcing them to reject something popular.”

The SPD knows this dynamic well: They often face accusations of voting against their proclaimed ideals as the CDU’s coalition partner. “At the end of the day, the parties stand together for the government line and, of course, have to be measured against it to some extent,” says Sieberer. “But at the same time, of course, the battle over interpretation begins immediately.” Parties might claim to have wanted a different outcome, but to have been forced to make concessions to the coalition partner.

The Greens could be in that very position after the election. If the SPD remains where it is, a black-green coalition, consisting of the CDU, its sister party CSU and the Greens, would be likely. It is unclear who will become the strongest force and thus provide the chancellor. Either way: As part of a government coalition, the Greens would have to vote differently. “They will only introduce motions that are sure to have the support of the coalition,” says Sieberer.

Greens support motions in favor of open immigration policy

As an opposition party, the Greens have often introduced motions deemed too extreme by the governing parties. Among them are multiple requests for Germany to take in more refugees and asylum-seekers, including a motion from March 2020 to admit some 5,000 people from overcrowded Greek camps.

Baerbock and her party vote for more immigration and a more open refugee policy in almost all cases.

Little data on Scholz and Laschet

By contrast, the SPD’s Scholz and the CDU’s Laschet have a relatively thin voting record on the topic. Publicly, the SPD politicianspoke out in favor of accepting more refugees from Moria after fires destroyed the Greek camp in 2020. When large numbers of refugees arrived in Germany during 2015 and 2016, he pleaded for more European cooperation and faster processing procedures for asylum applications, but also advocated for stricter controls at the EU borders and more stringent deportation procedures.

For Laschet, only two roll-call votes on the topic are recorded, both on opposition motions in state parliament. Generally, the CDU politician and former integration minister for North Rhine-Westphalia is seen as astaunch supporter of a multicultural society, and in 2015, he backed Merkel’s open refugee policy in the face of criticism. As Merkel’s policy got stricter, though, so did his.

Selective support for military missions abroad

German soldiers are currently deployed on a total of 12 missions around the world. These are generally decided on by the government, but most must be approved by parliament.

Infografik - Grüne stimmen über Bundeswehreinsätze ab - EN

The Greens, as part of the opposition, have supported only some of these missions. For example, Baerbock has always voted along party lines against German military involvement in NATO’s Sea Guardian operation, which is meant to ensure security in the Mediterranean, and against the missions in Iraq and Syria. Other missions have the support of the Greens, however, such as those in North Africa and Lebanon.

Greens most active on climate policy

Environmental policy is the key issue for the Greens. During Baerbock’s time in the Bundestag, the Greens have repeatedly introduced motions on the topic, such as a fundamental ban on fracking, as well as an exit from coal by 2022.

Data visualization Germany chancellor candidate comparison environment

Many of these motions have little chance of success and serve primarily to position themselves politically, Sieberer explains. But the Greens also generally support government motions that strengthen climate policy and nature conservation, except for protest votes on motions they deem insufficient.

Repeatedly rejecting opposition motions drags down Merkel’s own track record on climate policy. Still, Merkel and her ruling coalition support more than half of all motions for more climate and nature protection. Her government has helped introduce and implement some environmental policy decisions in recent years, such as theclimate protection program 2030 and an increase in aviation tax rates. But she and her party also voted, for example, to cut solar power subsidies.

Laschet’s climate hesitancy

Once again, there is less data on Laschet and Scholz, who more often vote on regional issues in state parliament.

In his few roll-call votes on environmental issues, Laschet has voted against motions on animal welfare andenvironmental protection. In public, Laschet is often hesitant in his support of climate policies. In his home state, coal still plays a major role. This may be one reason the CDU candidate always emphasizes the importance of industry and economy when talking about climate protection.

Greens agree with government coalition on EU cooperation

Motions on European cooperation are usually introduced by the governing coalition and therefore mostly pass. On this issue, the Greens introduce fewer motions themselves, but support the CDU/CSU and their coalition partners in motions ranging from financial aid for Greece to the start of EU accession talks with Albania in 2019 to participation in the EU’s pandemic crisis support in 2020.

Being in the opposition, the Greens have agreed with the governing coalition surprisingly often in the past years, Sieberer notes: “It seems a bit like they’re preparing for possible future government participation. You can’t disagree with everything if you want to govern together with the same people later.”

 





Source link

Previous Post

Climate friendly cooling tech firm gets $50 mln from Goldman Sachs

Next Post

How toy industry giants are going green

GrR

GrR

Green Reporter is a global source for news of sustainability, green industry, green technology, clear energy, sustainable food production, and green investments. Our aim is to deliver the best news and information to you.

Next Post
How toy industry giants are going green

How toy industry giants are going green

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Climate change in our backyard: Manitoba begins to grapple with the consequences – Winnipeg

Climate change in our backyard: Manitoba begins to grapple with the consequences – Winnipeg

August 10, 2021
Repsol starts marketing debut sustainability-linked bond sale

Repsol starts marketing debut sustainability-linked bond sale

June 29, 2021
Sustainability Ambitions Soaring at KCI

Sustainability Ambitions Soaring at KCI

December 6, 2021
Chris Pratt explains where the White Spikes originated

Chris Pratt explains where the White Spikes originated

July 3, 2021
Stop burning our rights! What governments and corporations must do to protect humanity from the climate crisis – World

Stop burning our rights! What governments and corporations must do to protect humanity from the climate crisis – World

Biden said to mull dropping corporate tax hike to fund jobs plan

Biden said to mull dropping corporate tax hike to fund jobs plan

Global investors pressure Asian utilities to cut emissions

Global investors pressure Asian utilities to cut emissions

Global inequity could derail path to net zero

Global inequity could derail path to net zero

The Power of PLM to Drive Sustainability in Fashion

The Power of PLM to Drive Sustainability in Fashion

October 4, 2023
Climate change damage to infrastructure poses ‘huge’ financial risks

Climate change damage to infrastructure poses ‘huge’ financial risks

October 4, 2023
UAE company, Swiss Tech provider partner to transform energy and renewable chemistry

UAE company, Swiss Tech provider partner to transform energy and renewable chemistry

October 4, 2023
Stirling scientists’ role in food source initiative to help tackle climate change

Stirling scientists’ role in food source initiative to help tackle climate change

October 4, 2023

Recent News

The Power of PLM to Drive Sustainability in Fashion

The Power of PLM to Drive Sustainability in Fashion

October 4, 2023
Climate change damage to infrastructure poses ‘huge’ financial risks

Climate change damage to infrastructure poses ‘huge’ financial risks

October 4, 2023
UAE company, Swiss Tech provider partner to transform energy and renewable chemistry

UAE company, Swiss Tech provider partner to transform energy and renewable chemistry

October 4, 2023
Stirling scientists’ role in food source initiative to help tackle climate change

Stirling scientists’ role in food source initiative to help tackle climate change

October 4, 2023

Recent News

The Power of PLM to Drive Sustainability in Fashion

The Power of PLM to Drive Sustainability in Fashion

October 4, 2023
Climate change damage to infrastructure poses ‘huge’ financial risks

Climate change damage to infrastructure poses ‘huge’ financial risks

October 4, 2023
UAE company, Swiss Tech provider partner to transform energy and renewable chemistry

UAE company, Swiss Tech provider partner to transform energy and renewable chemistry

October 4, 2023

Browse by Category

  • Biodiversity
  • Climate Change
  • Energy
  • Filmmaking
  • Food
  • Investment
  • Management
  • Sustainability
  • Technology
  • Transportation

Follow Us

  • Privacy & Policy
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise

© 2021 Copyright Green Reporter

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Biodiversity
  • Climate Change
  • Energy
  • Filmmaking
  • Food
  • Investment
  • Management
  • Sustainability
  • Technology
  • Transportation

© 2021 Copyright Green Reporter